© Media Watch 10 (3) 453-470, 2019
ISSN 0976-0911 E-ISSN 2249-8818
News Sources as a Propaganda Filter: The New York Times Coverage of Palestine and Kosovo Unilateral Approaches of Statehood Recognition
AMER QASEM & ADNAN BIN HUSSEIN
Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia
This paper examines the New York Times performance about the use of news sources in reporting unilateral approaches of statehood recognition. Following a critical perspective, the Propaganda Model is employed as a theoretical thrust. It argues that the free accessibility granted to the voices of government and its international allies is among the filters that affect the construction of media discourse. Two case studies are selected for juxtaposition, namely: Palestine and Kosovo. Both states are qualified to be internationally recognized according to international law theories. The unilateral approach of Palestine is firmly opposed by the U.S. government—unlike Kosovo. The analysis reveals a structural bias in favor of the U.S. foreign policy of statehood recognition. The news sources were positioned in a dichotomous order: “our” voices versus “theirs.” Specific news sources (i.e., the Russians) holding “opponent” views have been either completely suppressed or reverberated the voices of the “others/enemies.”
Keywords: News sources, New York Times coverage, manufacturing consent, Palestine and Kosovo, propaganda model, statehood recognition
Altheide, D. (1984). Media hegemony: A failure of perspective. Public Opinion Quarterly, 48(2), 476-490.
Al Waheidi, M., & Rudoren, J. (January 15, 2015). Rival Palestinian checkpoints in Gaza show cracks in reconciliation pact. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1645507741.
Aqtash, N., Seif, A., & Seif, A. (2004). Media coverage of Palestinian children and the Intifada. Gazette: The International Journal for Communication Studies, 66(5), 383-409.
Arqoub, O., & Ozad, B. (2019). Israel media gatekeeper during Gaza War 2014 coverage: Case of study of Yedioth Ahronotho newspaper. Media Watch, 10(1), 22-40.
Bacon, W., & Nash, C. (2003). How the Australian media cover humanitarian issues. Australian Journalism Review, 25(2), 5-30.
Bacon, W., & Nash, C. (2004). Stories in distress: Three case studies in Australian media coverage of the humanitarian crisis. Australian Journalism Review, 26(1), 19-39.
Baker, P. (July 22, 2010). Conflicts resurface with lessons on nation-building. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 626172364.
Bagdikian, B. (2004). The new media monopoly. Boston: Beacon Press.
Balabanova, E. (2010). Media power during humanitarian interventions: Is Eastern Europe any different from the West? Journal of Peace Research, 47(1) 71-82.
Balabanova, E. (2017). Media, war, and politics: Comparing the incomparable in Western and Eastern Europe. 2nd ed. Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Company.
Bennett, W., Lawrence, R., & Livingston, S. (2007). When the press fails: Political power and the news media from Iraq to Katrina. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bennett, W. (2016). News: The politics of illusion, 10th ed. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Bennett, W. (1990). Toward a theory of press-state relations in the United States. Journal of Communication 40(2), 103-125.
Bharthapudi, K. (2012). Save “us” and let “them” die: Critical discourse analysis of how New York times sold U.S. policies toward Rwandan genocide and Kosovo crisis. Doctoral Dissertation, Carbondale: Southern Illinois University.
Bilefsky, D. (April 26, 2008). Serbia’s most famous survivor fears that recent history will repeat itself. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433825629.
Bilefsky, D. (July 23, 2010). Kosovo’s declaration of independence is within the law, U.N. rules. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 642532589.
Bilefsky, D. (March 18, 2008). Dozens hurt as Serbs clash with Kosovo peacekeepers. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433808873.
Bilefsky, D. (March 25, 2008). Serbia, formally urging partition of independent Kosovo, is rebuffed by Albanians. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433798371.
Boaz, C. (2005). War and foreign policy framing in international media. Peace Review: A Journal of Social Justice, 17(4), 349-356.
Boyd-Barrett, O. (2004). Judith Miller, the New York Times, and the Propaganda Model. Journalism Studies, 5(4), 435-449.
Bronner, E., & Hauser, C. (November 30, 2012). U.N., in blow to the U.S., heightens the status of Palestine. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1220784002.
Brunwasser, M. (October 2, 2011). Support slips for Serbian autonomy in a new country. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 895684379.
Brown, J., Bybee, C., Wearden, S., & Straughan, D. (1987). Invisible power: Newspaper news sources and the limits of diversity. Journalism Quarterly, 64(1), 45-54.
Chaney, D. (1981). Public opinion and social change: the social rhetoric of documentary and the concept of news. In E. Katz and T. Szecsko (Eds.) Mass media and social change (pp. 115-136). Beverly Hills: Sage.
Chomsky, N. (1991). International terrorism: Image and Reality. In A. George (Ed.), Western state terrorism (pp. 12-43). New York: Routledge.
Chomsky, N. (2016). Who rules the world? London: Hamish Hamilton.
Cooper, H., Chivers, C., & Clifford, J. (August 18, 2008). How a squabble became a showdown. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433908074.
Dempsey, J. (July 28, 2011). Kosovo firebombing underscores new ethnic tensions. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 879455948.
Dickson, S. (1992). Press and US policy toward Nicaragua, 1983-1987: A study of the New York Times and Washington Post. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 69(3), 562-571.
Dixon, M. (2005). Textbook on international law (5th Ed). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
DiMaggio, A. (2017). The Propaganda Model and manufacturing consent: U.S. public compliance and resistance. In J. McGilvray (Eds.), the Cambridge Companion to Chomsky, 2nd ed., (pp. 275-294). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dimitrova, D., & Connolly-Ahern, C. (2007). A tale of two wars: Framing analysis of online news sites in coalition countries and the Arab World during the Iraq War. The Howard Journal of Communications, 18(2), 153-168.
Falk, R. (2013). Foreword. In M. Qafisheh (Eds.), Palestine membership in the United Nations: Legal and practical implications, (pp. xv-xix). Newcastle: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Gordon, M. (August 24, 2008). A democratic leader on foreign policy, in Iraq and, earlier, the Balkans. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433906037.
Gordon, M., & Landler, M. (November 29, 2012). U.S. and Israel look to limit the impact of U.N. vote on Palestinian Authority. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1220561602.
Grinberg, N., Joseph, K., Friedland, L., Swire-Thompson, B., & Lazer, D. (2019). Fake news on Twitter during the 2016 U.S. presidential election. Science, 363(6425), 374-378.
Guyot, J. (2009). Political-economic factors are shaping news culture. In: P. Preston (Eds.), Making the news: Journalism and news culture in Europe, (pp. 92-109). London: Routledge.
Hadid, D. (March 19, 2015). Palestinian leaders see validation of their statehood effort. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1664387376.
Hallin, D. (1984). The media, the war in Vietnam, and political support: A critique of the thesis of an oppositional media. The Journal of Politics, 46(1), 2-24.
Hall, S., Critcher, C., Jefferson, T., Clarke, J., & Robert, B. (1978). Policing the crisis: Mugging, the state, and law and order. London: The MacMillan Press LTD.
Herman, E., & Chomsky, N. (1988). Manufacturing consent: The political economy of mass media. New York: Pantheon Books.
Herman, E., & Chomsky, N. (2002). Manufacturing consent: The political economy of mass media. 2nd ed., New York: Pantheon Books.
Herman, E., & Peterson, D. (2000). CNN: Selling NATO’s war globally. In P. Hammond and E. Herman (Eds.) Degraded Capability: The media and Kosovo Crisis (pp. 111-122). London: Pluto Press.
Herman, E. (1993). The media’s role in U.S. foreign policy. Journal of International Affairs, 47(1), 23-45.
Herman, E (2000). The propaganda model: A retrospective. Journalism Studies, 1(1), 101-112.
Herman, E. (1996). The propaganda model revisited. Monthly Review, 48(3), 115-128.
Herman, E. (2018). The Propaganda Model revisited. Monthly Review, 69(8), 42-54.
Hertog, J. (2000). Elite press coverage of the 1986 US-Libya conflict: A case study of tactical and strategic critique. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 77(3), 612-627.
Hertsgaard, M. (1988). On bended knee: The press and Regan presidency. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux.
Hossain, M. (2015). Manufacturing consent: Framing the liberation war of Bangladesh in the U.S. and UK media. Journalism, 16(4), 521-535.
Ismail, A. (2010). When the “fortress crumbled”: The Israel-Jenin story in US news media. Communication, Culture & Critique, 3(1), 66-84.
Kennis, A. (2015a). Indexing state-corporate propaganda? Evaluating the indexing, propaganda, and media dependence models on CNN and CNN en Español’s coverage of Fallujah, Iraq. Global Media and Communication, 11(2), 103-130.
Kennis, A. (2015b). An unworthy social movement? An evaluation of the Media Dependence Model and the news media performance of the New York Times on Vieques. Communication, Culture & Critique, 9(3), 438-457.
Kershner, I. (May 5, 2014). After failed peace talks, pushing to label Israel as occupier of Palestine. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1520722332.
Koehler, D. (2016). Can journalistic “False Balance” distort public perception of consensus in expert opinion? Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 22(1), 1-11.
Kozol, W. (2004). Domesticating NATO’s war in Kosovo/a: (In) visible bodies and the dilemma of photojournalism. Meridians, 4(2), 1-38.
Kruger, U. (2015). Manufacturing consent through integration: Social networks of German journalists in the elite milieu and their effects on coverage. European Journal of Communication, 30(2), 152-170.
Kulish, N., & Chivers, C. (February 19, 2008). The U.S. and much of Europe recognize Kosovo, which also draws expected rejection. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433779509.
Lancaster, K. (2008). New media coverage of the Iraq war in Basra, fall 2007: A case study in “spinning” news for the state. International Journal of Communication, 2, 976-992.
Lauterpacht, H. (1947). Recognition in international law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Lippmann, W. (1922). Public opinion (1st Ed.). New York: Harcourt, Brace, and Company.
MacLeod, A. (2018). Manufacturing consent for the 2018 Elections in Venezuela and Colombia. Media Theory, 2(2), 138-153.
MacLeod, A. (2019). Manufacturing consent in Venezuela: Media misreporting of a country, 1998-2014. Critical Sociology, 1-18:https://doi.org/10.1177/0896920518820934
Martin, S., & Hansen, K. (1998). Newspapers of record in a digital age: From hot type to hot link. Connecticut: Greenwood Publishing Group.
Moon, M. (2018). Manufacturing Consent? The role of the international news on the Korean Peninsula. Global Media and Communication, 14(3), 265-281.
Muravchik, J. (1985). Perceptions of Israel in the American media: Summary of a conference. New York: The Institute on American Jewish-Israeli Relations.
Noaks, J., & Wilkins, K. (2002). Shifting frames of the Palestinian movement in US news. Media Culture & Society, 24(5), 649-671.
Panganiban, S. (2016). Palestinian statehood: A study of statehood through the lens of the Montevideo Convention. Master Dissertation. Alexandria: Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
Phillips, P. (2008). Left-progressive media inside the Propaganda Model. In P. Phillips, A. Roth with Project Censored (Eds.), Censored 2008: The top 25 censored stories of 2006-07 (p. 233). New York: Seven Stories Press.
Qasem, A., & Hussein, A. (2018). “Law and order” vs. “injustice and defiance”: Al Jazeera and CNN framing of the 2017 Temple Mount/Al Aqsa Mosque Crisis. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 9(1), 25-34.
Rich, R. (1993). Recognition of states: The collapse of Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union. European Journal of International Law, 4(1), 36-65.
Ross, S. (2003). Framing of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in thirteen months of New York Times editorials surrounding the attack of September 11, 2001. Conflict & Communication Online, 2(2), 1-11.
Rudoren, J., & Hadid, D. (May 14, 2015). Pope aids push for statehood by Palestinians. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1680652906.
Rudoren, J. (January 1, 2015). Palestinians set to seek redress in a world court. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 1641163999.
Schwalbe, C., & Dougherty, S. (2015). Visual coverage of the 2006 Lebanon War: Framing conflict in three U.S. news magazines. Media, War & Conflict, 8(1), 141-162.
Schwalbe, C. (2013). Visually framing the invasion and occupation of Iraq in Time, Newsweek, and U.S. News & World Report. International Journal of Communication, 7(1), 239-262.
Ten Eyck, T., & Williment, M. (2003). The national media and things genetic coverage in the New York Times (1971-2001) and the Washington Post (1977-2001). Science Communication, 25(2), 129-152.
Traub, J. (August 10, 2008). Taunting the bear. The New York Times. ProQuest Document ID: 433918368.
Zaller, J., & Chiu, D. (1996). Government’s little helper: U.S. press coverage of foreign policy crises, 1945-1991. Political Communication, 13(4), 385-405.
Zollmann, F. (2017). Media, propaganda, and the politics of intervention. New York: Peter Lang.
Amer Qasem is a Ph.D. candidate at the School of Communication, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia. His areas of research interest include political communication, critical discourse analysis, media representation, and propaganda studies.
Adnan Bin Hussein (Ph.D., University of Utah, the United States, 1994) is a professor at the School of Communication, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Malaysia. His areas of research interest include environmental communication, new media, and communication theory.